Can I prohibit trustee investment in fossil fuel companies?

The question of whether you can prohibit a trustee from investing in fossil fuel companies is increasingly common, reflecting a growing desire to align investment portfolios with personal values. Generally, the answer is yes, *if* it’s clearly stipulated in the trust document itself. Trusts are governed by state law, primarily the Uniform Trust Code adopted in many jurisdictions, and these laws afford a good deal of flexibility to the grantor – the person creating the trust. However, simply *wanting* to avoid fossil fuels isn’t enough; the instruction must be explicit and unambiguous within the terms of the trust. This is where the guidance of an estate planning attorney, like Steve Bliss here in San Diego, becomes critical. Roughly 60% of millennials and Gen Z investors express a strong desire for socially responsible investing, demonstrating a clear shift in investor preferences (Source: Morgan Stanley Sustainable Investing Report, 2023).

What are the legal limitations on trustee investment choices?

Trustees have a fiduciary duty to act in the best interests of the beneficiaries, and traditionally that meant maximizing financial returns. However, modern interpretations of fiduciary duty are evolving, recognizing that beneficiaries’ values can be a legitimate consideration, *provided* those values are clearly expressed in the trust document. There’s a legal principle called the “prudent investor rule,” which requires trustees to make reasonable investment decisions with regard to risk and return, diversifying the portfolio appropriately. A blanket prohibition on *all* fossil fuel investments might be deemed overly restrictive if it significantly limits the potential for reasonable returns. However, a well-drafted clause can specify *types* of fossil fuel companies to avoid – for example, those involved in coal extraction or tar sands oil – or it could set percentage limits on exposure to the sector.

How specific do I need to be in the trust document?

Specificity is paramount. Vague language like “no investments in environmentally harmful industries” is open to interpretation and could lead to disputes. The trust should clearly define what constitutes a “fossil fuel company” – is it limited to extraction, or does it include transportation, refining, and even companies that derive a significant portion of their revenue from fossil fuels? It’s also wise to anticipate potential future developments. For example, the trust could include a clause addressing investments in companies that are transitioning away from fossil fuels but still have some exposure. Steve Bliss often advises clients to include a “values statement” in their trust documents, outlining their broader ethical principles, even if they don’t specify every single investment restriction. This provides guidance to the trustee in situations not explicitly covered by the terms.

Can a trustee be held liable for violating my wishes?

Yes, a trustee can be held liable if they knowingly violate the explicit instructions in the trust document. Beneficiaries can petition the court to compel the trustee to comply with the terms of the trust or to remove the trustee for breach of fiduciary duty. The consequences can include financial penalties and even personal liability. However, the trustee also has a duty to act reasonably, and if they believe that strictly adhering to the restriction would be detrimental to the beneficiaries’ financial interests, they may seek court guidance. Documentation is crucial. The trustee should keep a detailed record of all investment decisions and the reasons behind them, demonstrating that they considered both the grantor’s wishes and their fiduciary duty.

What happens if the restriction impacts investment performance?

This is a common concern. Prohibiting investments in a specific sector can limit diversification and potentially reduce returns. A trustee must balance the grantor’s values with the need to achieve reasonable investment performance. It’s important to remember that ethical investing doesn’t necessarily mean sacrificing returns. Many sustainable investment strategies have performed competitively with traditional approaches, particularly in recent years. Furthermore, as the world transitions to a low-carbon economy, companies focused on renewable energy and other sustainable technologies are likely to outperform those reliant on fossil fuels. A carefully crafted restriction can allow the trustee to invest in companies that align with both the grantor’s values and their financial goals.

I once advised a client, Eleanor, who deeply regretted not including such a clause in her trust.

Eleanor had a substantial estate and a strong commitment to environmental sustainability, but her trust document was silent on the issue of fossil fuel investments. After her passing, her trustee – a large financial institution – continued to invest a significant portion of the trust assets in oil and gas companies. Eleanor’s daughter, fiercely committed to her mother’s values, was heartbroken and frustrated. She felt powerless to change the situation and ultimately had to resort to costly legal action to try and compel the trustee to align the investments with her mother’s wishes. The legal battle was protracted and emotionally draining, highlighting the importance of proactive planning. She spent nearly 20% of the inherited estate just fighting to realign the portfolio.

Recently, I helped a client, Mark, implement a solution for his family.

Mark, a retired engineer, was adamant that his trust not support fossil fuel companies. We drafted a clause that specifically prohibited direct investments in companies primarily engaged in the extraction, refining, or transportation of fossil fuels. We also included a provision allowing the trustee to invest in companies that were actively transitioning to renewable energy sources. Mark felt immense relief knowing that his wealth would be used in a way that aligned with his values. His trust now invests in a diversified portfolio of sustainable technologies, renewable energy projects, and socially responsible companies. The portfolio has performed well, demonstrating that ethical investing can be both financially rewarding and personally fulfilling. His daughter, as co-trustee, regularly reviews the portfolio, ensuring alignment with his principles.

What are the potential tax implications of restricting investments?

Restricting investments doesn’t usually have direct tax implications. However, if the restriction leads to lower overall returns, it could indirectly affect the amount of income or capital gains generated by the trust, which could impact the tax liability. It’s also important to consider the potential for “sin taxes” or other regulations that may apply to certain industries, such as fossil fuels. These regulations could affect the value of investments in those industries. A qualified tax advisor can help you understand the potential tax implications of your investment restrictions and ensure that your trust is structured in a tax-efficient manner. Approximately 15% of investors actively avoid investing in companies with poor environmental, social, or governance (ESG) practices (Source: MSCI ESG Research, 2022).

About Steven F. Bliss Esq. at San Diego Probate Law:

Secure Your Family’s Future with San Diego’s Trusted Trust Attorney. Minimize estate taxes with stress-free Probate. We craft wills, trusts, & customized plans to ensure your wishes are met and loved ones protected.

My skills are as follows:

● Probate Law: Efficiently navigate the court process.

● Probate Law: Minimize taxes & distribute assets smoothly.

● Trust Law: Protect your legacy & loved ones with wills & trusts.

● Bankruptcy Law: Knowledgeable guidance helping clients regain financial stability.

● Compassionate & client-focused. We explain things clearly.

● Free consultation.

Map To Steve Bliss at San Diego Probate Law: https://maps.app.goo.gl/X4ki3mzLpgsCq2j99

Address:

San Diego Probate Law

3914 Murphy Canyon Rd, San Diego, CA 92123

(858) 278-2800

Key Words Related To San Diego Probate Law:

conservatorship law dynasty trust generation skipping trust
trust laws trust litigation grantor retained annuity trust
wills and trust attorney life insurance trust qualified personal residence trust



Feel free to ask Attorney Steve Bliss about: “Should I put my retirement accounts in a trust?” or “What are the common mistakes made during probate?” and even “What documents are included in an estate plan?” Or any other related questions that you may have about Trusts or my trust law practice.